Both of us ended up near DC and we wanted to try out Johnny’s happy hour specials. Sadly we were looking and the last time we paid for a meal in DC was in May.
 |
- Stella Artois – Somehow I was expecting a bit more for a happy hour $5 special. However it tasted fine.
|
 |
- Bread – Bread was really hard and a bit bland for our tastes.
|
 |
- She Crab Soup – Only a tiny bit of crab in the soup. Also a weird exchange. I asked what the soup of the day was (pointing to the $4 entry on the menu). The bartender goes “She-Crab soup”. We go ok. The bill comes and it is marked $7.50.
|
 |
- New Orleans Filé Gumbo – Nice spices and kick to the soup. I did like how the seafood felt as it it had been cooked in the soup right before it came out. Not like it had been sitting in the pot for a few hours. There was a slight crisp to the shrimp. The fish was done well and the oysters had a good character to them.
|
 |
- Classic Maryland Crab Cake – We choose broiled between broiled and fried. Large chunks of jumbo crab in the cake. Nice pop and also sweetness to the crab. No sense of bread filler in the crab. Served with a very mild mustard based sauce and a very mild coleslaw on the side whose natural sweetness combined well with the crab. Another error with the cashier not taking the happy hour discount.
|
 |
- Fried Oysters – The wife’s favorite. Nice crunch on the outside with the bread crumbs. However the center of the oysters were cooked perfectly, almost melting with juices in one’s mouth when eating them. Served with a pickled sweet assortment of vegetables which was light and refreshing. Very perfectly executed with the Bearnaise sauce.
|
 |
- Mini-Burger – Not a fan of the Mini burger, a bit on the greasy side. Sloped on with cheese, onion, mustard and ketchup. Same bread as below but it didn’t really work as then it made the burger more greasy than it needed to be.
- Mini Asian Tuna Sandwich – We were huge fans of the tuna. So much so we ordered a few more. Some of the tuna was throughly cooked, some had a raw center. We were bigger fans of the slightly raw in the center ones. Mixed with a sesame, radish sprouts in a light aioli. The slightly buttered breaded went well with the tuna.
|
Decor: The happy hour specials are only at the bar. Service is basically a drop and go, you go tot he bar order, the come drop the food off and leave. Be careful when the bill comes as I think our server tried to rip us off. First he charges full price for the crabcake instead of the happy hour price, he also charged us two dollars more than the full price of the soup. When I order I asked him what was the happy hour soup, he goes she crab soup. So I’m a bit flabbergasted when he charges more than full price of the soup, not even more the happy hour price. I go what’s the deal with the soup? He goes sorry the she crab not part of the happy hour. Fine then why is it two dollars more than the full price of the regular soup? So in the end he tried to charge me $4 more than the happy hour price. And he was rude and getting angry with me. Hey buddy, I didn’t charge more than what was on the menu.
Overall Assessment: ($$, 6/10) – We think the food was great. The server and his attitude about the check was a total buzz kill on what would have been a good meal. major deductions on the service. Also you can get free parking after five so bonus on that. Good value for a DC seafood restaurant if you are able to sneak in for the happy hour specials. Though it will start to add up if you add a lot of things together. Just be careful of the staff.
Website: http://www.johnnyshalfshell.net/
Location: 400 N Capitol St NW, 20001
Reservation: OpenTable
Takeout: 202.737.0400
Hours: Mon – Fri; 0700 – 0930, 1130 – 1430, 1630 – 2200 Sat; 1700 – 2200